Cardio vs Resistance Training: Which is best For Weight-Loss & does lifting weights make women bulky?
Many people who’ve decided to lose weight find themselves stuck with a tricky question; should they do cardio or lift weights?
They’re the two most popular types of workouts, but it can be hard to know which is a better use of your time.
Cardio Burns More Calories Per Session
There is so much research available on how many calories people burn during various activities. Based on this research, you can use your body weight to estimate how many calories you will burn during different types of exercise, including cardio and resistance (weight) training.
For most activities, the more you weigh, the more calories you will burn:
If you weigh 73-75 kg, you will burn about 250 calories per 30 minutes of jogging at a moderate pace
If you were to run at a faster pace of 6 miles per hour, you would burn around 365 calories in 30 minutes
On the other hand, if you do a resistance based workout for the same amount of time, you might only burn around 130–220 calories.
In general, you’ll burn more calories per session of cardio than weight training for about the same amount of effort.
In short: The number of calories you burn during exercise depends on your body size and how intensely you exercise. Typically, a cardio workout burns more calories than a weight training workout of the same duration.
BUT.....
Weight Training Helps You Burn More Calories Every Day

Although a weight-training workout doesn’t typically burn as many calories as a cardio workout, it has other important benefits. For example, weight training is more effective than cardio at building muscle, and muscle burns more calories at rest than some other tissues, including fat. Because of this, it is commonly said that building muscle is the key to increasing your resting metabolism (RMR) — that is, how many calories you burn at rest.
One study measured participants’ resting metabolisms during 24 weeks of weight training.
In men, weight training led to a 9% increase in resting metabolism. The effects in women were smaller, with an increase of almost 4%. While this may sound good, it’s important to think about how many calories this represents.
For the men, resting metabolism increased by about 140 calories per day. In women, it was only about 50 calories per day. Therefore, weight training and building a little bit of muscle won’t make your metabolism skyrocket, but it may increase it by a small amount.
However, weight training also has other important calorie-burning benefits. Specifically, research has shown that you burn more calories in the hours following a weight training session, compared to a cardio workout. In fact, there are reports of resting metabolism staying elevated for up to 38 hours after resistance training, the same cannot be said with cardio workouts.
This means that the calorie-burning benefits of weights aren’t limited to when you are exercising. You may keep burning calories for hours or days afterward.
For most types of exercise, a more intense workout will increase the number of calories you burn afterward.
In short: Weight training may improve your metabolism over time, although the changes aren’t huge. Also, weight
training is typically more effective than cardio at increasing the number of calories you burn after a workout.
High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) May Burn More Calories

There are loads of studies that have directly compared the effects of cardio workouts, resistance training and HIIT workouts.
One study compared the calories burned during 30 minutes of HIIT, weight training, running and biking. The researchers found that HIIT burned 25–30% more calories than the other forms of exercise. This is great news for you as our timetable is packed full of amazing HIIT workouts in the form of our SWEAT BMT & FMT sessions.
It’s worth saying however, that this doesn’t necessarily mean that other types of exercise aren’t good for weight loss.
It's also worth noting that a variety of styles can be even more effective than just singling out one style when it comes to shedding the fat and losing weight.
If we then consider adding resistance to our SWEAT sessions we can further increase the benefits. i.e, by using weights like dumbbells, barbells and kettlebells.
But there seems to be a problem with this and it's time to get rid of this outdated idea once and for all. It's the suggestion that if women lift weights, they will get ‘bulky’!
If I Lift Weights Will I Get Bulky?

Let me be clear. Women will not "bulk up" if they lift weights; even heavy ones!
People often use the term "bulky" in a negative way to describe others, typically women, who have large muscles or well-defined physiques.
As weightlifting gained popularity and edged its way into mainstream culture, many women developed a fear of turning into Arnold Schwarzenegger if they so much as touched a 5kg dumbbell.
Now let me make a few very important points. Firstly, women won't bulk up if they start lifting weights; second, lifting weights produces so many health benefits; and third, it's blatantly sexist to think women shouldn't look muscular anyway.
Here are four reasons to stop believing that strength training (or using heavier weights) makes women bulky.
It's actually hard to build muscle
This is good news for some, bad news for others. It's great news for women who are afraid of packing on too much muscle. Building lots of muscle is a long, slow process that requires years of consistency, dedication and effort.
Most people don't put in enough time or effort to create the kinds of physiques they're scared of. I've been trying for years and I’m still not there 😉 haha. It takes several years to put on the kind of mass that bodybuilders have, and there's a reason professional bodybuilders are an elite few.
They will train with incredibly heavy weights, sometimes multiple times per day for hours at a time. They will also be in a calorie surplus, not deficit. They aren’t trying to lose weight, they are actually trying to gain weight! Also, commonly, they are taking anabolic steroids which dramatically increases the ability to build muscle.
Women don't have enough testosterone to get bulky
In general, women don't produce as much testosterone as men. Testosterone production is a huge factor in the capacity for muscle growth, so this should automatically tell you that you won't turn into Arnie overnight.
Of course, there are always exceptions: Some women have higher testosterone levels than other women, but even those with higher-than-average testosterone, they likely don't have enough to produce bulky muscles.
Many women don't eat enough to build big muscles
Going back to an earlier point. To build muscle, you must eat more calories than you burn. You can't grow new tissue out of nothing, so don't expect lots of muscle growth if you're eating in a calorie deficit or even at maintenance calories. Many women don't eat enough calories or enough protein to support significant muscle growth.
For reference, the recommended calorie intake for a healthy woman is between 1,800 and 2,400 calories. If you exercise, you probably need to meet the higher end of that range, and potentially more if you're tall or very active. Unless you're eating more than your maintenance intake each day, don't worry about getting bulky.
Many women don't lift heavy (or often) enough to get bulky
Muscles don't grow in response to tasks they're used to. Your muscles need a challenge: If you're not progressively overloading (consistently lifting heavier and heavier weights) your muscles on a regular basis, you're not encouraging your muscles to grow. They have no reason to get bigger if there is no demand.
So if you’ve been using the same weights for a while, your body will quickly adapt and find balance.
To add lots of muscle mass, you need follow two primary rules with your workouts:
1. Lift in the correct rep range for muscle growth (usually 6 to 15 reps per set)
2. Lift until you reach muscle fatigue
During our workouts these 2 factors will NOT usually be met and therefore you shouldn’t worry about getting bulky.
What's more is that those two techniques only work for so long and eventually, as you get stronger and fitter, you'll also need to add in new weightlifting techniques and training styles to send stronger muscle-building signals to your brain.
Frequency (number of workouts close together) is another key factor in building muscle. Studies show that when you train a muscle more often, it grows more in a shorter period of time. However, as with volume, there are caps on this concept. The stronger and fitter you get, the less of an impact frequency has on muscle growth.
Why women should lift weights

Women won't bulk up when they start lifting weights. What they will do, though, is lose body fat and earn the "toned" appearance so many people are after. Beyond aesthetics though, women who lift weights will experience loads of health benefits.
Lifting weights can:
Improve your bone density and help prevent osteoporosis, a degenerative bone
disease common in older women
Aid in weight loss (if you want to lose weight)
Improve your body composition (increase lean mass and reduce fat mass - This is
what we want)
Reduce your risk of chronic diseases
Improve your mental health
Improve your flexibility and mobility
Make you feel strong, empowered and confident
In Summary
The take home message is that variety is the spice of life, so vary what you do on our weekly timetable. Come to a variety of sessions and challenge yourself each time. And if you want to add in some classic cardio in the form of running, cycling, walking, swimming etc. we completely support this.
During our SWEAT sessions however, don't fear using heavier weights. There are so many benefits to using larger weights and very few negatives. And you certainly wont get bulky! You’ll actually accelerate your progress and more than likely, get to your goal faster than you thought possible.
We simply want you to think about your goals and then look at the equipment you have been using during our workouts.
I'm sure some of you will agree that your weights feel a little easy for the majority of the exercise you do. If that's the case, do some investigating and think about investing in your health and taking your fitness and strength to the next level. Have a look at our ‘Useful Equipment’ list under ‘Useful Resources’ at the top of this programme to see your suggestions for good home gym equipment.
You’ve got this!
See you at a workout soon.

